1) Search
2) Review
3) Submit

Buylist Magic Cards

Tip: Bulk Items adds bulk RARE/MYTHIC, Paste List Paste cards or whole decklist, FAQ / Guide Explains our process. Click any button to open.

    Choose which finish you’re selling. Normal = non-foil, Foil = foil, Etched = etched-foil. Prices shown match the finish you pick.
    0 items Cash: 0.00 Credit: 0.00

    How do you want to sell?

    Sell List

    Submit an itemized request.

    • Best for most customers — fast, accurate estimates using our card search & list builder.
    • Submit a list, choose your condition/finish, and we’ll confirm details before you ship.
    • Works for small to large collections. Great when you want the strongest payout with clear pricing.
    SELL MAGIC: THE GATHERING

    Sell in Person

    Meet our buyers at select events.

    • Best if you want a face-to-face review and immediate offer at an event.
    • We may prioritize higher-value cards or sealed products depending on event capacity.
    • Availability varies — check the current schedule before traveling.
    REQUEST AN APPOINTMENT

    Ship + Sell

    Sell a large collection by mail.

    • Best for large collections — no need to sort everything perfectly.
    • We verify condition/finish on arrival, then finalize your quote and payout.
    • Simple process: Submit → Ship → Verify → Get paid.
    CONTACT US